Porting a pyModeS BDS register to FlightJar

FlightJar's Comm-B decoder matches pyModeS 3.x byte-for-byte. When adding another register, keep the wire behaviour identical so we can cross-check golden vectors from pyModeS's own test corpus. Every deviation (even a "cleanup") is a source of silent drift later.

Touchpoints

A full port spans six files and one frontend + one docs update:

1. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Decoder/ModeS/CommB.cs — add IsBdsXX(payload) validator + DecodeBdsXX(payload) decoder + BdsXXData record. Extend the Candidates record and Infer() to include the new register.
2. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Decoder/ModeS/DecodedMessage.cs — add one field per value the register exposes.
3. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Decoder/ModeS/MessageDecoder.cs — add a branch in InferCommB that builds a DecodedMessage for the new register; extend Merge() to copy the new fields.
4. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Core/State/Aircraft.cs — add per-field state + one BdsXXAt timestamp.
5. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Core/State/AircraftRegistry.cs — add a case "X,Y": branch in ApplyCommB that writes the fields + stamps the timestamp. Extend BuildCommBSnapshot to gate the fields on freshness and feed the SnapshotCommB record.
6. dotnet/src/FlightJar.Core/State/RegistrySnapshot.cs — add the fields to SnapshotCommB (nullable, snake-case on the wire).
7. app/static/detail_panel.js — add metric tiles to the .panel-met-grid placeholder markup in buildPopupContent and a set('.pop-met-xxx', …) call per field in renderCommBSection.
8. dotnet/tests/FlightJar.Decoder.Tests/ModeS/CommBTests.cs — validator accept/reject tests + golden-vector decoder tests using hex captures from pyModeS's tests/test_bds_commb.py.
9. README.md — add the new fields to the "Enhanced Mode S air data" bullet and flag any register-specific caveats.
10. CLAUDE.md — update the decoder list + any behavioural nuances.

Step 1 — Fetch the pyModeS reference

pyModeS lives at junzis/pyModeS on GitHub (default branch main). BDS decoders live under src/pyModeS/decoder/bds/bdsXX.py, helpers under _helpers.py. Fetch into /tmp/pymodes/ via the GitHub API (the raw CDN sometimes 404s; the contents API is reliable):

bash
1# List available registers.
2curl -sL "https://api.github.com/repos/junzis/pyModeS/contents/src/pyModeS/decoder/bds?ref=main" \
3  | grep '"download_url"'
4
5# Fetch a specific register + the shared helpers.
6for f in bds45 _helpers _infer; do
7  curl -sL "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/junzis/pyModeS/main/src/pyModeS/decoder/bds/$f.py" \
8    > /tmp/pymodes/$f.py
9done
10
11# And the golden-vector test corpus.
12curl -sL "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/junzis/pyModeS/main/tests/test_bds_commb.py" \
13  > /tmp/pymodes/test_bds_commb.py

Step 2 — Port the validator + decoder

pyModeS operates on a 56-bit payload as a Python int with (payload >> (55 - i)) & mask indexing (MSB-first from payload bit 0). The C# port keeps identical bit indexing so the ported arithmetic reads one-to-one next to the Python. Add your new methods inside public static class CommB in CommB.cs.

Use the existing helpers that are already in CommB.cs:

• WrongStatus(payload, statusBit, valueStart, valueWidth) — mirrors pyModeS _helpers.wrong_status (status-bit / value-field consistency).
• Signed(value, width, sign) — sign-magnitude to signed int (NOT two's complement; Mode S splits sign + magnitude bits).
• NormaliseAngle(deg) — wrap into [0, 360).

Every range gate in IsBdsXX must match pyModeS's validator. If pyModeS rejects > 600 kt but you port it as >= 600, you will silently accept values pyModeS would reject.

Step 3 — Wire into inference

CommB.Infer(payload) returns a Candidates record with one bool per heuristic register. MessageDecoder.InferCommB(msg) returns a decoded message only when exactly one candidate validates. This single-match discipline is intentional: multi-match payloads are ambiguous and dropped rather than risk polluting aircraft state with fields decoded against the wrong register. Do not relax it without a replacement disambiguation strategy (e.g. pyModeS Phase 3 known-state scoring).

BDS 4,5 (meteorological hazard) is opt-in in pyModeS because it false-positives on non-meteorological payloads. When porting, keep the validator strict; if ambiguity becomes a problem, add a Candidates.Bds45 branch behind a config flag rather than unconditionally accepting it.

Step 4 — Extend state + snapshot

For every decoded field:

1. Add a nullable property to Aircraft (e.g. public int? WindshearLevel { get; set; }).
2. Add an identically-named property to SnapshotCommB.
3. In ApplyCommB, add a case "X,Y": that assigns from the DecodedMessage; do not touch fields from other registers (each register owns its own slice of state).
4. In BuildCommBSnapshot, compute a bdsXXFresh flag using CommBMaxAge (120 s) and use it to gate every field from the register. Include the register's BdsXXAt timestamp on the snapshot so the frontend can age values out independently.

Naming convention on the wire: snake_case via the global serializer config in FlightJar.Api.Configuration. MagneticHeadingDeg becomes magnetic_heading_deg without any extra attributes.

Step 5 — Extend the frontend panel

The Enhanced Mode S panel is driven entirely by a.comm_b in the snapshot. In detail_panel.js:

1. Add placeholder tile markup inside .panel-met-grid in buildPopupContent — same shape as existing tiles (<div class="metric pop-met-xxx" hidden><div class="label">…</div><div class="val"></div></div>).
2. Add a set('.pop-met-xxx', value) call in renderCommBSection that computes the formatted string or returns null to hide the tile.

Use the existing uconv('alt' | 'spd' | 'vrt' | 'dst', value) helper for unit-system-aware formatting. Raw-unit values (Mach, temperature, degrees, percent) format inline.

Step 6 — Tests

CommBTests.cs follows two patterns; use both for the new register:

1. Validator acceptance + rejection: pick a golden-vector hex from pyModeS's test_bds_commb.py, assert IsBdsXX accepts it, then construct synthetic payloads that should be rejected (all zeros, out-of-range values, status-bit / value-bit inconsistency) and assert they're rejected.
2. Decode golden vector: decode the pyModeS golden hex and assert each field matches the pyModeS oracle value to within the same abs= tolerance the pyModeS test uses.

Also add an end-to-end test in MessageDecoder_RoutesUnambiguousBdsXXOnDf20 to prove the InferCommB branch wires through.

Step 7 — Add an integration test

dotnet/tests/FlightJar.Core.Tests/State/AircraftRegistryTests.cs + FakeDecoder.cs use fake hex keys (BD44 → pre-built DecodedMessage) to exercise ApplyCommB + BuildCommBSnapshot without real wire bytes. Add a BDxx fixture and a test proving the new field lands in the snapshot and ages out correctly past CommBMaxAge.

Step 8 — Playwright smoke (optional)

The detail panel renders Enhanced Mode S section when comm_b is present test in tests/e2e/layout.spec.js injects a fake snapshot with a full comm_b block. If the new register adds a user-visible tile, extend the fixture and assert the new label appears.

Step 9 — Verify

bash
1cd dotnet && dotnet format FlightJar.slnx --verify-no-changes
2dotnet build FlightJar.slnx
3dotnet test FlightJar.slnx
4cd ..
5node --test tests/js/
6npx playwright test

All five must pass before the port is done. Formatter drift and Playwright regressions are the two most common surprises.

Do not

• Do not rename pyModeS's field names in the decoded record unless you have a codebase-wide reason. static_air_temperature in pyModeS is StaticAirTemperatureC in CommB.cs — the C suffix is the only concession, and it's there because our wire convention suffixes every physical-unit field.
• Do not persist Comm-B state in state.json.gz. The 120 s freshness window is far shorter than the 30 s persist cadence + 10 min PersistMaxAge, so restored Comm-B values would be stale on load.
• Do not bypass CommB.Infer's single-match gate by eagerly decoding every register. Multi-match payloads mean one of the decodes is wrong; you cannot tell which without an external reference signal, so dropping ambiguous payloads is the safe default.
• Do not add register-specific env vars for opt-in registers without updating README.md's configuration reference table.