Bug Reproduction Framework
Given a Linear ticket context ($ARGUMENTS), systematically reproduce the bug with a failing regression test.
Step 1: Parse Signals
Extract the following from the provided ticket context:
- Error message / stack trace (if provided)
- Reproduction steps (if provided)
- Workflow JSON (if attached)
- Affected area (node, execution engine, editor, API, config, etc.)
- Version where it broke / last working version
Step 2: Route to Test Strategy
Based on the affected area, pick the test layer and pattern:
| Area | Test Layer | Pattern | Key Location |
|---|---|---|---|
| Node operation | Jest unit | NodeTestHarness + nock | packages/nodes-base/nodes/*/test/ |
| Node credential | Jest unit | jest-mock-extended | packages/nodes-base/nodes/*/test/ |
| Trigger webhook | Jest unit | mock IHookFunctions + jest.mock GenericFunctions | packages/nodes-base/nodes/*/test/ |
| Binary data | Jest unit | NodeTestHarness assertBinaryData | packages/core/nodes-testing/ |
| Execution engine | Jest integration | WorkflowRunner + DI container | packages/cli/src/__tests__/ |
| CLI / API | Jest integration | setupTestServer + supertest | packages/cli/test/integration/ |
| Config | Jest unit | GlobalConfig + Container | packages/@n8n/config/src/__tests__/ |
| Editor UI | Vitest | Vue Test Utils + Pinia | packages/frontend/editor-ui/src/**/__tests__/ |
| E2E / Canvas | Playwright | Test containers + composables | packages/testing/playwright/ |
Step 3: Locate Source Files
Find the source code for the affected area:
- Search for the node/service/component mentioned in the ticket
- Find the GenericFunctions file (common bug location for nodes)
- Check for existing test files in the same area
- Look at recent git history on affected files (
git log --oneline -10 -- <path>)
Step 4: Trace the Code Path
Read the source code and trace the execution path that triggers the bug:
- Follow the call chain from entry point to the failure
- Identify the specific line(s) where the bug manifests
- Note any error handling (or lack thereof) around the bug
Step 5: Form Hypothesis
State a clear, testable hypothesis:
- "When [input/condition], the code does [wrong thing] because [root cause]"
- Identify the exact line(s) that need to change
- Predict what the test output will show
Step 6: Find Test Patterns
Look for existing tests in the same area:
- Check
test/directories near the affected code - Identify which mock/setup patterns they use
- Use the same patterns for consistency
- If no tests exist, find the closest similar node/service tests as a template
Step 7: Write Failing Test
Write a regression test that:
- Uses the patterns found in Step 6
- Targets the specific hypothesis from Step 5
- Includes a comment referencing the ticket ID
- Asserts the CORRECT behavior (test will fail on current code)
- Also includes a "happy path" test to prove the setup works
Step 8: Run and Score
Run the test from the package directory (e.g., cd packages/nodes-base && pnpm test <file>).
Classify the result:
| Confidence | Criteria | Output |
|---|---|---|
| CONFIRMED | Test fails consistently, failure matches hypothesis | Reproduction Report |
| LIKELY | Test fails but failure mode differs slightly | Report + caveat |
| UNCONFIRMED | Cannot trigger the failure | Report: what was tried |
| SKIPPED | Hit a hard bailout trigger | Report: why skipped |
| ALREADY_FIXED | Bug no longer reproduces on current code | Report: when fixed |
Step 9: Iterate or Bail
If UNCONFIRMED after first attempt:
- Revisit hypothesis — re-read the code path
- Try a different test approach or layer
- Maximum 3 attempts before declaring UNCONFIRMED
Hard bailout triggers (stop immediately):
- Requires real third-party API credentials
- Race condition / timing-dependent
- Requires specific cloud/enterprise infrastructure
- Requires manual UI interaction that can't be scripted
Output: Reproduction Report
Present findings in this format:
Ticket: [ID] — [title] Confidence: [CONFIRMED | LIKELY | UNCONFIRMED | SKIPPED | ALREADY_FIXED]
Root Cause
[1-2 sentences explaining the bug mechanism]
Location
| File | Lines | Issue |
|---|---|---|
path/to/file.ts | XX-YY | Description of the problem |
Failing Test
path/to/test/file.test.ts — X/Y tests fail:
test name— [failure description]
Fix Hint
[Pseudocode or description of the fix approach]
Important
- DO NOT fix the bug — only reproduce it with a failing test
- Leave test files in place as evidence (don't commit unless asked)
- Run tests from the package directory (e.g.,
pushd packages/nodes-base && pnpm test <file> && popd) - Always redirect build output:
pnpm build > build.log 2>&1 - DO NOT look at existing fix PRs — the goal is to reproduce from signals alone
